Yesterday morning I woke up thinking, "I cheated." I had eaten every bit of that wrap only to realize too late that it contained turkey. How could I have been so careless? In a matter of seconds though, it became apparent that it was only a dream. Sigh of relief. My subconscious was playing tricks on me. Interestingly, I actually haven't craved meat or thought twice about passing up the chicken teriyaki bowl at Benji's since starting this new lifestyle last week. (I will say that saying no to salmon has proven to be slightly difficult.) I think my general ease in becoming a vegetarian is due to the fact that prior to now I haven't eaten much meat anyway. I never consciously limited my meat intake, its appeal just slowly dwindled over time.
By making this conscious decision to not eat meat, I feel that I have, in a sense, come closer to asserting my ecological self. Arne Naess describes the term ecological self as a "person's 'process of identification.'" He says that to be an ecological self, "behavior naturally and beautifully follows strict norms of environmental ethics." The ecological self understands and respects relationships with others, especially with other animals and the environment. By saying no to the immoral practices of large factory farms and the inefficiency of the transportation of meat, I am actively respecting my relationship with chickens and the environment. No longer are animals simply a means to my nutrition nor is the energy intensive process of growing food for the animals, again, a mere means to my sustenance. Now, I feel like I am a more active and conscious member of this community that we all share.
I know that all of my actions aren't aligned with my ideal ecological self but I'm getting closer day by day. On Tuesday, I helped start basil seeds for the CC Farm. By being involved in the process of planting and growing food, I've thought more about my relationship with the land. Yes, in a way tilling a plot of land and planting food for human consumption is using the land as a means, but, for me, it is not mere means. I respect the land. Agriculture is tangible proof of the power and importance of the land. This week, I plan on helping out more at the farm to solidify my relationship with the land.
The question I will consider this week: How can I continue to improve and strengthen my ecological self? Acting out of pure self-direction is somewhat difficult in the time we live in, as we are constantly bombarded with images and pre-defined societal norms from the media, but I hope that by improving my relationship with the environment, I will achieve a better understanding of myself in defining my ecological self.
Update: After our discussion today(4/9) in class, I've come to realize how extreme the deep ecology movement is. Naess asks that we partake in a fundamental shift in our society. Although I may have been simplifying Naess' ideas, I do think he'd agree with me in that the actions I have been taking do improve my ecological self (although specifically identifying with every leaf is somewhat foreign to me). I guess basing the improvement of my ecological self on my relationship with other beings and the environment (rooted in respect) is more along the lines of Leopold's ideas in the Land Ethic. In the Land Ethic, Leopold says that humans are a member of the biotic community with a duty to preserve and respect this biotic community. In short, my idea of an ecological self combines the ideas of Naess and Leopold.
Nicole,
ReplyDeleteNice posts -- reflective and thoughtful. I like the way you connect to the readings. The discussion of the ecological self does seem consistent with Naess' basic idea. I do think that Naess envisions a *process* of widening and deepening the self -- he doesn't imagine that we'll suddenly wake up one day and identify with every living thing. And I'm not sure he would even say that we have to have with all living things we encounter the kind of vivid experience of identification he describes with the flea in order to achieve self-realization. I think his idea is that as we develop the capacity to identify with and empathize with other living things, this enables us to have a broader sense of our selves as connected with all life, and not fundamentally separate from other living things. But it remains a radical view, and one that envisions substantial social transformation. Leopold, too, is radical in his way, but as we discussed, his view is not as strongly revisionist in an ontological sense. I look forward to hearing more about how your project goes!